Penname: aglaja5 Real name: Heike
Member Since: Oct 18, 2016
Membership status: Member
Bio:

[Report This]
Reviews by aglaja5
Summary:

Brian told Justin to get some friends his age – what if the kiss Michael saw was misconstrued? What if miscommunication was only the start of it all? Just how far does the butterfly effect go? 


Categories: QAF US
Characters: Brian Kinney, Ethan Gold, Justin Taylor, Original Male Character
Tags: Jealousy, Overdose, PTSD, Rage, Real Life Issues, Season 3, Tearjerker, What if...
Genres: Angst
Pairings: Brian/Justin
Series: None
Chapters: 36 Table of Contents
Completed: No Word count: 195503 Read Count: 59853
[Report This] Published: Nov 15, 2017 Updated: Aug 12, 2019
Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: Jan 23, 2022 Title: Chapter 1: Chapter 1

Hi! I swore to myself never to read unfinished stories again but a friend recommented your story to me several times. So I started to read... And what can I say... You got me so hooked up! It's very well written and the storyline with Ethan being in a relationship and Justin "only" found himself some friends "his age" is something I never read so far. An incredible good idea! And I have to admit, I already read till chapter 6. After reading the first chapter, there were so many questions in my mind, that are already answered! But again, an amazing story, and an heartbreaking first chapter!

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed
Date: Jan 23, 2022 Title: Chapter 2: Chapter 2

Thanks for another incredibly intense chapter! These glimpses into their thoughts are very interesting. "Brian locked the man he had shown Justin away" - Oh, I so agree with Daphne. You mention all those events that I also hated so much about S2 and Brian's behavior. I mean, really, a hustler for a birthday? It would have been so much better if he hadn't given him anything. But that was about the most disrespectful thing he could do. And it hurts me so much to see Justin's face, the joy, then the disappointment and how he tries to pretend he's happy for Brian afterwards. There were already so many little hurtful disrespectful things with whom Justin could deal before the bashing, because he had an almost naive, courageous, self-confident and enthusiastic way of approaching life, but after prom and after everything he had to experience at the age of 17! And that scene "Take a shower. You stink"! I can understand so well that this experience could completely destroyed Justin mentally - it was so cruel. And while reading this chapter and thinking about it, I wonder how the authors could deal with the bashing and the aftermath so carelessly...There would be so much more to say about all the things that happened between Brian and Justin in S1 and in S2 and about their effects...

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: Jan 24, 2022 Title: Chapter 11: Chapter 11

Great chapter! You convincingly show how Brian opens up more with each session and although he often remains cynical, he speaks more and more the truth and becomes more thoughtful. It sure helps that Alex tells him his story. Alex knows exactly what's at stake, regarding not just Brian and Justin, but also about the detrimental influence of a "best friend" and childhood traumatas and their effect on adults. He sees himself in Brian, maybe that's why he risked Justin's trust by bringing Brian to Boytoy...

"once. Those were the rules, right?" - haha, great!

"You need therapy even more than Justin" - I totally agree

"Not my reputation - he saw me."  - beautiful!

As for that "achievements" thing... I found a lot of Brian's life mottos kind of silly. It's like he created them at some point and can't let go of them. I don't think it's cool, it's just sad and a little pathetic, because somehow sticking to those life mottos also means that he can't develop further. Thanks for a great chapter!

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed
Date: Jan 23, 2022 Title: Chapter 4: Chapter 4

What a great and intense chapter. First the glimpses into Brian's mind, who is finally confronted with what he did and the impact it had. He's done some cruel things to Justin before, but as I've already previously written, that "Take a shower. You stink"-scene is probably the most horrible thing Brian has done to Justin. Yes, mental abuse. Debbie later says, "I don't know what set him off, Brian." Brian should know. And yes, I know it's a TV series, but they started so many interesting storylines and then didn't finish them. They didn't let them talk enough. Whatever. And then that scene with Brian and Debbie. Very well written. "She laughed at me and said that you were the least of her concerns, that you were at least honest about the fact that you took pleasure in humiliating people." Heavy stuff, but not entirely untrue. "Justin said that he had been told that we would've been better off if you'd just left him lying there" - So, in your story, Michael didn't say that to Brian , but straight to Justin? Michael - what can I say, I don't like him at all, but I've always hoped that Brian and Michael would also have a clarifying conversation about their toxic addiction friendship - and not in the form that Brian offers Michael to fuck him.

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: Jan 23, 2022 Title: Chapter 3: Chapter 3

Oh, that's so sad! And on the show, while I don't particularly like Ethan, I think Ethan was necessary because both - Brian and Justin - learned something from it. Although I sometimes had my doubts about Brian (see for example that stupid 11:00 trick - well, whatever). But I'm glad that in your story and the situation he's in, Justin has such good friends in Ethan and Daphne and probably in Sam too.

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed
Date: Jan 23, 2022 Title: Chapter 5: Chapter 5

Thanks for another great chapter! Your writing style is so wonderful. I have to say when you mentioned Justin giving his POA to Daphne I was concerned that it might have had something to do with Sap's party and I was really worried that you might have changed that storyline and didn't let Justin got off so lightly there (I don't think he would had got away in real life. If these men had really wanted that, how could he have defended himself in his condition. But as I said, I'm glad you didn't change it. This storyline always touches and scares me very much).

Oh, and then the first time Michael opens his mouth, bullshit comes out again. What's wrong with him? "How were they kissing?" "Like you kiss me" - And that was also something that always annoyed me. Sure, those rules might have been a little silly, but why did Michael and Brian keep kissing all the time.. Oh, okay, was I too hasty? The last straw for Justin was the conversation between Justin and Michael. I just rewatched this scene in QAF and also without the awful line that Brian should have left Justin lying there, this scene and Michael's behavior is bad enough. "I have lost him and for what? A fucking kiss between friends?" - As I said, I really really don't like Michael and he's a big part of what's happening, but then again it's not that simple. They all contribute their share and Brian's share is not small either.

Debbie's speech to Michael is wonderful and she gets all things to the point! I also completely agree with Justin's classification of the family. You really have the gift of getting things straight to the point, including the way Lindsay is portrayed (that's exactly why I don't like her) - "the first and only Mrs. B.A Kinney" haha. Unfortunately, Brian sometimes didn't clearly draw the line here either. I love Mel's reaction at the end!

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: Jan 23, 2022 Title: Chapter 6: Chapter 6

And again, intense and amazing chapter! I like how you present Alex, how he's also coming straight to the point, not holding back. In this short conversation he already shows Brian so many truths, which Brian didn't see or didn't want to see, but which he hay to accept and deal with if he really wants to help Justin. And I'm sure he will choose the second choice! And then the real work begins because long before Justin needed therapy Brian would long already needed it. Don't get me wrong. I love Brian and I love Justin and I love their love, in my opinion they belong together. Both of them made mistakes and I didn't always or I did often not agree with the way the authors let them go through some storylines. Such complex characters, Brian who is already damaged when he meets Justin. Justin who goes through so much in the first season... So many interesting storylines which stayed sorts of open... And this damned 5. season with this stupid end where it looks as Brian just goes on to living his life as he has before Justin. Pathetic. I'm looking forward to continue to read your story because from what I've read so far I'm sure that you will open many of Brian's wounds and let him work through them. In order to help Justin he will have to really open himself!

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: Jan 24, 2022 Title: Chapter 12: Chapter 12

Ah, what can I say? Another great chapter! And I love that Brian confronted Gary S. and punched him out! Great!

Regarding Lindsay... I have to say I think about her as badly as I do of Michael. some "best friends" they are... She pits Mel and Brian against each other, even in the first scene. In my opinion, a child's name should be chosen in peace between the partners and not make it a contest. And while at times it seems like she's supportive of Brian and Justin's relationship and hopes Brian will grow up a little, there are also those totally opposite moments like before their wedding when she talks Brian into going to a crappy White Party instead attend her wedding!? Where he is going to do what? Fuck guys like every day? I didn't understand that at all!!!! In my opinion she is a manipulating bitch.

Alright, back to your story. OMG, that moment when Justin takes off his beanie, Gus recognizes him and the two of them are just so incredibly happy. Even if it was manipulative, i agree, he needed this moment of joy and happiness. Awesome!

Oh, and by the way, I really really like Sam!

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed
Date: Jan 24, 2022 Title: Chapter 13: Chapter 13

OMG how intense, how heartbreaking, how painful! What an amazing chapter! How fortunate that Brian was with Alex right now. He knows Justin and knows so well what he needs in those moments.

"You think you stalked me? I'll show you fucking stalking." - haha, yeah Brian, fight for your man!

That moment when they looked eyes for the first time. So beautiful. And even if it was just a short moment, it will maybe give Brian strength to fight and hold on, because the old Justin's still somewhere inside there. And even if it wasn't much, it was a start. They communicated for the first time. Regarding the daily nightly visits of Brian at the hospital - I really don't understand why Jennifer never told Justin. And I totally understand that this information doesn't help Justin at the moment an even makes him more angry. But this was a start and it's good that Justin at least agreed to talk to Alex again!

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed
Date: Jan 24, 2022 Title: Chapter 15: Chapter 15

Another small step in the right direction...

"He'd gotten 723 in Verbal/Writing when he had taken his SATs, and Brian damn well knew that - he'd laid Justin out and made him tell him all the different ways you could say fuck, sex, and cock while you had a vibrating plug in your ass and was having your cock sucked." - haha And although this is a very painful, intense and challenging story, you also manage to make me laugh/smile at times. It's so Brian Justin-ish

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: Jan 24, 2022 Title: Chapter 14: Chapter 14

Interesting to get a little insight into Brian's thoughts and it's another small step in the right direction that Justin is contacting Brian. They talked too little to each other on the show and kept too many things from each other. As I've written before, a lot of the so interesting storylines weren't finished in my opinion, were left open and you always wondered if the other person found out or not. But it was a TV show and it wasn't just about Brian and Justin...

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed
Date: Jan 24, 2022 Title: Chapter 16: Chapter 16

Ah, I like this new addition to Justin's little new family. Tommy seems to be a very kind and lovely guy. I have a bad feeling about this Roman and I hope history doesn't repeat itself here in any form. Of course it would be great if there was just someone normal who just had feelings for Tommy...

Oh, Debbie, my goodness, she just can't let it go either. But well, it's probably hard to break long and old habits...

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed
Date: Jan 24, 2022 Title: Chapter 17: Chapter 17

Wow! What an indescribably fantastic, painful, heartbreaking, shattering but also liberating chapter. "Rock bottom. Once you hit it, the only way you could go was up." Justin shows so much strength here, it's indescribable! "I was so used to hurting" - This whole chapter is heartbreaking but this sentence... I don't want to write anymore because my review couldn't do your chapter justice. This chapter is just perfect! Thanks so much for writing and sharing this unique story with us!

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed
Date: Jan 25, 2022 Title: Chapter 19: Chapter 19

*breathing* For me, this chapter felt like a little respite, a little break. ;-) A few positive things are happening. Michael finally seems serious about it and starting therapy (though I imagine Ben had a hand in it, but who knows). And it's wonderful how Emmett manages to build a tiny bit of trust in Justin. An important step in the right direction. Emmett is just a good soul and I always felt that he could be the closest thing to be a real friend to Justin. He is honest and the most authentic in my opinion. Beautiful chapter!

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: Jan 25, 2022 Title: Chapter 18: Chapter 18

Thank whomever, that Michael's not there - there should be just people involded who really care about Justin! And when Ethan starts to tell... it's so heartbreaking. Oh what am I writing, it's all so heartbreaking...

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed
Date: Jan 28, 2022 Title: Chapter 35: Chapter 35

Even if I get the feeling that Lindsay means it honestly and also regrets her behavior, I'm sorry, I just can't stand her. I honestly think it's cheeky that she took Gus to the playground when it was agreed that Mel would take him. And then she sits there and watches them both the whole time. It's like going to the zoo. No idea. In my opinion she kind of ruined the carefree time Justin wanted to spend with Gus. If I were Justin, that would have removed me further from her, but with this short greeting he shows that he seems to have more strength of character than I have... ;-)

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed
Date: Jan 27, 2022 Title: Chapter 31: Chapter 31

What a beautiful chapter! Finally they talk to each other, listen to each other, understand each other, accept each other. And after all these events, the only way for them is in my opinion to get to know each other again. And I love that thought that "I love you" isn't enough to describe Brian's feelings for Justin. I agree, but even that Justin needs to know first to understand it. ;-) "He'd caused that smile. He'd caused the laughter he could see dancing in Justin's eyes." - Beautiful! I wish them lots of such moments together! But... somehow I felt like Justin downplayed his experience with this trick. He has a really serious problem here and I think at some point he has to deal with it, it will come up. and after all, Brian still doesn't know the full extent....

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed
Date: Jan 27, 2022 Title: Chapter 32: Chapter 32

Ah, what a wonderful liberating chapter! A real turning point for Justin! At first I was scared, because you portray his conflict so wonderfully. The conflict to keep believing in the positive things, to believe in yourself or to let yourself fall back into the negative depressive thoughts. And one thing has also become clear, he can only do this himself. Of course, seeing how others saw things that happened can also help him. Hearing that other way of looking at things. But he himself must have the will to get out of it, to find himself again. And it seems he has that will now! love this story so much and thanks for sharing it with us!

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed
Date: Jan 28, 2022 Title: Chapter 33: Chapter 33

Ah, beautiful! I'm so happy for them. The continue on the path they have taken. And all the positive experiences will give Justin strength and help him to rebuild confidence in himself. It's in his kiss! "Can I take you out for dinner?" - So happy for them!

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: Jan 28, 2022 Title: Chapter 34: Chapter 34

This story is just amazing. Unbelievable good! Every chapter, every sentence, every word... "mine" That suits them so much better and also fits Brian's character. And no one else will know what is meant when Brian says that one word to Justin. This is so ridiculously romantic! I love it! You made me smile so hard! And I love that careful, slow process of how they get closer and closer and the mutual trust is built more and more. And while Justin still has his doubts, like I said, they're on the right path.

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: Jan 27, 2022 Title: Chapter 30: Chapter 30

At first it seemed like Michael had finally learned his lesson and he was on the right track. Why he then runs straight to Brian with this "new" information...no idea. I think it would have made more sense to go to Alex and tell him... But at least he's finally respecting Brian's privacy and using the doorbell instead of the key. I never understood that. I don't want people just walking into my apartment, even if they're my best friends. While I don't like the way Michael behaves here, as if he knows Justin, I do agree on one point about: "You don't use tricking as a form of punishment against them. You don't use their feelings against them". And I've written this many times, Brian has often used sex as punishment or to show Justin his place - and that is in my opinion an absolute no go. I'm curious how Brian will react when he finds out what this experience has done to Justin.

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed
Date: Jan 27, 2022 Title: Chapter 29: Chapter 29

Oh Justin! This was one of the absolutely saddest chapters so far. I really hope he doesn't have any internal injuries, but since you didn't mention that again, hopefully he'll be okay about that. This reminds me so much of one of my other favorite Conzieu fanfictions in which Justin also experiences mental rape at the hands of Brian. Brian still doesn't know what damage he's done. And the saddest thing is, of course, he wanted to hurt Justin, but I don't think he realized what he was doing with such careless, disrespectful and cruel treatment. Here in your story Brian's reaction is even more baseless, but even on the show I find it so disrespectful, so cruel. Because even if Justin cheated on Brian, it doesn't give him the right to treat another human being like that after he's treated Justin himself so many times disrespectfully and cruelly and carelessly. Now he will also reach the bottom.

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: Jan 26, 2022 Title: Chapter 27: Chapter 27

Everytime Alex says "Justin" or "Oh Justin" my heart breaks a little. And this chapter shows that it's absolutely necessary that they talk!!!! Brian means well, but everything he is doing, his actions, are interpreted differently or incorrectly by Justin because as I wrote before, how could he believe otherwise after everything. And also Brian still hasn't grasped the full extent of the damage...

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: Jan 25, 2022 Title: Chapter 21: Chapter 21

And again a perfect, painful but also beautiful chapter. I love your portrayal of Sam and Ethan so much and thankfully Justin has made such loyal loving friends. This talk, especially between Ethan and Brian, was important for mutual understanding. And I don't know why some sentences touch me more than others. So, as I said, almost every chapter is written so powerfully, so intensely, sadly, devastatingly and almost every sentence, every word moves me, but this sentence brought even more tears to my eyes "I took him to this little deli near your loft and he has his last one Money spent on food and wine."

Reviewer: aglaja5 Signed starstarstarstarstar
Date: Jan 25, 2022 Title: Chapter 22: Chapter 22

OMG, one step forward, two backwards. But I really didn't expect that. I was really hoping that things would slowly, slowly go uphill. Jeez! Jennifer. How could she? She should have spoken to Alex first. He would have known if Justin was ready to hear this or how to proceed. How stupid!

Ethan really is such a great friend! After talking to Brian, he knows that he really loves Justin and hopes that Brian can help Justin.

"you can't fix him.  Justin has to be the one who fixes himself" - totally agree. I don't have a lot of experience with depression, but it's not so unsimilar to addictions. You can't help a person addicted to alcohol, they have to take the step on their own and live with the disease for life.

"you showed me..." ahhh, my heart breaks... Justin also showed Brian so much more...